December 1, 2005

Appeals Court Will Review Sale/No Sale of SoCal PBS Station

Tuesday July 26th 2005, 11:54 am
Filed under: Right Watch, PBS

Southern California PBS station KOCE has successfully convinced an appeals court to review its decision overturning the sale of the station.

The Coast Community College District put KOCE up for sale in 2003. Although religious broadcasting company Daystar bid on the affiliate, station officials chose to sell the station to a group of local interests that promised to maintain the station’s educational purpose. Daystar sued for religious discrimination and a court overturned the sale. (For more, see “Religious Broadcaster, Community, Battle for Ownership of PBS Station.”)

KOCE asked the court to review the decision. Yesterday, it agreed.

From the LA Times:

The 4th District Appellate Court’s action might include another hearing, but the justices are more likely to reexamine materials already filed. The judges could come to almost any decision, from allowing the original sale to go though to deciding the station should be sold to the Daystar Television Network.

There is no deadline for the court to make a decision.


The college district and Daystar both asked the appeals court to review its decision after it canceled the sale and said the district could either keep the station or hold another round of bidding. Daystar, which the court said made the highest bid, wants the court to order the district to sell the station to the televangelism firm.

The district argues that the judges’ original decision was wrong and the station should remain in the foundation’s hands.

Richard Lloyd Sherman, a lawyer for Texas-based Daystar, said it was unlikely the court would completely change its mind. “Based on the language of their original ruling, they’re not going to change the basic opinion,” he said.

Milford Dahl, the district’s attorney, said, “It’s not necessarily a positive sign, but at least we don’t have an adverse opinion right now.”

KOCE President Mel Rogers was more confident. “We believe that once all the facts in the case are clarified, we’ll get a good result,” he said.

Daystar also has sued the district and the foundation in federal court, accusing them of violating the law to keep a Christian broadcaster from buying the station.

Previous: Colorado Springs Free Speech Suit Tossed || Home || Next: Telus Update

2 Comments so far

The ruling was bogus.

The owners should be able to sell to new owners based on the content they’re expecting the new owners to show.

Comment by Eric Jaffa 07.26.05 @ 12:52 pm

I am obviously dense. What precisely is the violation of law in this case? Is it discrimination on the basis of religion? Surely there can’t be a law that requires the station to be sold to the highest bidder? Daystar’s original complaint (as reported here) only makes reference to their religious point of view when they say that they were “wrongfully and illegally prevented” from buying the station.

Comment by Brent McKee 07.27.05 @ 11:22 am

Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Your e-mail address is never displayed. Basic HTML is allowed. Including more than one link makes you look like a spammer and will cause your comment to be held in moderation.